Broken record: UN entry, Mountbatten’s prejudice and the Grand Mufti’s letter
Why This Matters
Key context: <p>Pakistan’s long and fruitful association with the United Nations began formally in the last week of September, as its application for UN membership was accepted. In other major developments, Louis Mountbatten was accused of throwing Muslim employees in Delhi under the bus, while the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin Al Hussaini, issued a fervent appeal through <em>Dawn</em> to highlight Palestine’s plight.</p> <h2><a id="un-membership" href="#un-membership" class="heading-permalink" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" title="Permalink"></a><strong>UN membership</strong></h2> <p>There were two major diplomatic achievements for Pakistan in the last week of September. The first was the young country’s acceptance as a member of the UN, then known as the United Nations Organisation (UNO). This was no small feat, as membership announced that Pakistan was ready to take its place in the comity of nations.</p> <p>‘Dominion of Pakistan unanimously accepted for UNO membership’, the headline from the Sept 26 edition read. Pakistan received all 35 votes, though an interesting procedural question was raised by the Argentine representative. The report filed from Lake Success, NY (where the UN was based before shifting to its current headquarters in Manhattan in 1951), said: “The Dominion of Pakistan was unanimously recommended for membership in the UNO … by the Political Committee of the General Assembly. The resolution received the committee’s full 35 votes, but only after the Argentine delegate, Senor Jose Arce, objected to the necessity for Pakistan to apply for membership at all.”</p> <figure class='media w-full sm:w-full media-- media--uneven media--stretch' data-original-src='https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp'> <div class='media__item '><picture><img src='https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp' width='1200' height='1880' srcset='https://i.dawn.com/thumbnail/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp 300w, https://i.dawn.com/medium/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp 500w, https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp 1200w' sizes='(min-width: 1024px) 890px, 100vw' alt='' /></picture></div> </figure> <p>Of course Senor Arce held no malice towards Pakistan; in fact he wanted to introduce Pakistan as a Charter member (India was already a Charter member, having joined the UN while still a British colony in 1945). As the report pointed out, “it was clear in the course of the debate that nobody was questioning the present status of India as member of the UNO, or the desirability of Pakistan becoming a member. … [The question] was whether a member of the UNO, if split into two separate nations, would create a situation in which two seats in the UNO were automatically available.</p> <p>“The Argentine’s case was that either Pakistan and India were both automatically members, or that neither were members until they had been formally admitted.”</p> <p>Thankfully the diplomatic debate was resolved amicably, and Pakistan was admitted. It was interesting to note that despite the intense Partition-related violence, the Indian delegation, which was present during the debate, did not oppose Pakistan’s membership. Perhaps, on one level, those were more civil times.</p> <h2><a id="washingtons-man-in-karachi" href="#washingtons-man-in-karachi" class="heading-permalink" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" title="Permalink"></a><strong>Washington’s man in Karachi</strong></h2> <p>Another major diplomatic development during this period was the appointment of America’s first ambassador to Pakistan. As detailed in a report in the Sept 24 edition, US President Harry S. Truman appointed Mr Paul H. Alling as Washington’s first envoy to Pakistan.</p> <p>Unlike many of the questionable characters that the current White House has posted at foreign missions, Mr Alling was a seasoned diplomat. Washington’s man in Karachi had sterling credentials, as he was chief of the State Department’s division of Near Eastern affairs, while he had also advised the American delegation to the UNO.</p> <figure class='media w-full sm:w-full media-- media--uneven media--stretch' data-original-src='https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/221059592f9190b.webp'> <div class='media__item '><picture><img src='https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/221059592f9190b.webp' width='1200' height='1880' srcset='https://i.dawn.com/thumbnail/2026/11/221059592f9190b.webp 300w, https://i.dawn.com/medium/2026/11/221059592f9190b.webp 500w, https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/221059592f9190b.webp 1200w' sizes='auto, (min-width: 1024px) 890px, 100vw' loading='lazy' alt='' /></picture></div> </figure> <p>Moreover, Mr Alling had served as US Consul in Beirut, Syria as well as other posts in the Middle East. Meanwhile, Pakistan’s first ambassador to the US, tycoon and diplomat Mirza Abol Hassan (M.A.H.) Ispahani, had already arrived in America.</p> <p>The appointment of the American ambassador would mark the start of one of Pakistan’s most important — and most complex — foreign relationships.</p> <h2><a id="mountbattens-prejudice" href="#mountbattens-prejudice" class="heading-permalink" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" title="Permalink"></a><strong>Mountbatten’s prejudice?</strong></h2> <p>Louis Mountbatten, the last British viceroy of India, is known to have had cool relations with Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah, while enjoying cordial ties with Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. ‘Dickie’ Mountbatten was apparently slighted by the fact that the Quaid chose to be the first Governor-General of Pakistan, whereas the Indians readily accepted him for the same post in their country. But did this bitterness turn Mountbatten into a prejudiced man? A report from the Sept 28 edition seems to suggest so.</p> <p>Titled ‘Sack Muslim staffs, says Mountbatten to diplomats’, the report says that “Lord Mountbatten sent for all the foreign diplomats stationed in Hindustan’s capital … and told them that they should immediately get rid of their Muslim employees.</p> <p>“They were told that if they sheltered Muslims or gave protection to their own employees, the Government of India would not be responsible for their safety.”</p> <figure class='media w-full sm:w-full media-- media--uneven media--stretch' data-original-src='https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp'> <div class='media__item '><picture><img src='https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp' width='1200' height='1880' srcset='https://i.dawn.com/thumbnail/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp 300w, https://i.dawn.com/medium/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp 500w, https://i.dawn.com/large/2026/11/2210595953bf79d.webp 1200w' sizes='auto, (min-width: 1024px) 890px, 100vw' loading='lazy' alt='' /></picture></div> </figure> <p>It added that “all these diplomats sent their Muslim employees and domestic servants to the various refugee camps. … It is also significant that Lord Mountbatten was not able to protect his own Muslim employees and domestic servants, some of whom were killed and wounded.”</p> <p>If these reports are true, they would shatter the myth of empire being a benevolent, benign force, and expose it as ruthless and vengeful, even in its dying days.</p> <h2><a id="grand-muftis-letter" href="#grand-muftis-letter" class="heading-permalink" aria-hidden="true" tabindex="-1" title="Permalink"></a><strong>Grand Mufti’s letter</strong></h2> <p>This newspaper’s commitment to the Palestinian cause goes back to the time of Independence. In fact, Haj Amin Al-Hussaini, the Grand Mufti of Al-Quds, had written to <em>Dawn</em> asking the paper to raise awareness about Palestine’s plight.</p> <p>As chronicled in the Sept 28 issue, Haj Amin wrote that “Undoubtedly you know the dangers threatening Palestine because of the Zionist imperialistic aims, and because of the decisions of the United Nations’ Special Committee on Palestine in dividing Palestine into two States — an Arab and a Jewish — although the majority of the Jews in Palestine are foreigners who entered Palestine by force of British arms after the British occupation.</p> <p>“We are in urgent need of your help to raise your strong voice in disapproving the UNSCOP report and to do your best in order to save Palestine, the first Qiblah and the third Masjid from the dangers threatening her.”</p> <p>Haj Amin was a prescient man and could see what was coming for his people. Sadly, 79 years after the Mufti’s impassioned appeal, the people of Palestine continue to suffer from Zionist terrorism.</p> <hr /> <p><em>With the advantage of hindsight, one has the opportunity to study the historical cycles in a nation’s life. Thanks to this newspaper’s unique, extensive archive of back issues, one can examine the major political, economic and social trends that have shaped Pakistan and the world over the last seven decades and counting. Cliched as it may sound, history repeats itself, and we — as a state and as a polity — largely refuse to learn from it.</em></p> <p><em>Through this platform, we will look back at the ‘big’ stories that made it to the front pages of Dawn, as well as significant developments tucked away in the inside pages, from the birth of Pakistan onwards, and try to put them in perspective. We will study the critical issues of the week, starting from Aug 14, 1947 and examine the major themes and issues that made it to the paper.</em></p> This development from dawn.com highlights ongoing changes in the sector.
Pakistan’s long and fruitful association with the United Nations began formally in the last week of September, as its application for UN membership was accepted. In other major developments, Louis Mountbatten was accused of throwing Muslim employees in Delhi under the bus, while the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Haj Amin Al Hussaini, issued a fervent appeal through Dawn to highlight Palestine’s plight. UN membership There were two major diplomatic achievements for Pakistan in the last week of September. The first was the young country’s acceptance as a member of the UN, then known as the United Nations Organisation (UNO). This was no small feat, as membership announced that Pakistan was ready to take its place in the comity of nations. ‘Dominion of Pakistan unanimously accepted for UNO membership’, the headline from the Sept 26 edition read. Pakistan received all 35 votes, though an interesting procedural question was raised by the Argentine representative. The report filed from Lake Success, NY (where the UN was based before shifting to its current headquarters in Manhattan in 1951), said: “The Dominion of Pakistan was unanimously recommended for membership in the UNO … by the Political Committee of the General Assembly. The resolution received the committee’s full 35 votes, but only after the Argentine delegate, Senor Jose Arce, objected to the necessity for Pakistan to apply for membership at all.” Of course Senor Arce held no malice towards Pakistan; in fact he wanted to introduce Pakistan as a Charter member (India was already a Charter member, having joined the UN while still a British colony in 1945). As the report pointed out, “it was clear in the course of the debate that nobody was questioning the present status of India as member of the UNO, or the desirability of Pakistan becoming a member. … [The question] was whether a member of the UNO, if split into two separate nations, would create a situation in which two seats in the UNO were automatically available. “The Argentine’s case was that either Pakistan and India were both automatically members, or that neither were members until they had been formally admitted.” Thankfully the diplomatic debate was resolved amicably, and Pakistan was admitted. It was interesting to note that despite the intense Partition-related violence, the Indian delegation, which was present during the debate, did not oppose Pakistan’s membership. Perhaps, on one level, those were more civil times. Washington’s man in Karachi Another major diplomatic development during this period was the appointment of America’s first ambassador to Pakistan. As detailed in a report in the Sept 24 edition, US President Harry S. Truman appointed Mr Paul H. Alling as Washington’s first envoy to Pakistan. Unlike many of the questionable characters that the current White House has posted at foreign missions, Mr Alling was a seasoned diplomat. Washington’s man in Karachi had sterling credentials, as he was chief of the State Department’s division of Near Eastern affairs, while he had also advised the American delegation to the UNO. Moreover, Mr Alling had served as US Consul in Beirut, Syria as well as other posts in the Middle East. Meanwhile, Pakistan’s first ambassador to the US, tycoon and diplomat Mirza Abol Hassan (M.A.H.) Ispahani, had already arrived in America. The appointment of the American ambassador would mark the start of one of Pakistan’s most important — and most complex — foreign relationships. Mountbatten’s prejudice? Louis Mountbatten, the last British viceroy of India, is known to have had cool relations with Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah, while enjoying cordial ties with Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru. ‘Dickie’ Mountbatten was apparently slighted by the fact that the Quaid chose to be the first Governor-General of Pakistan, whereas the Indians readily accepted him for the same post in their country. But did this bitterness turn Mountbatten into a prejudiced man? A report from the Sept 28 edition seems to suggest so. Titled ‘Sack Muslim staffs, says Mountbatten to diplomats’, the report says that “Lord Mountbatten sent for all the foreign diplomats stationed in Hindustan’s capital … and told them that they should immediately get rid of their Muslim employees. “They were told that if they sheltered Muslims or gave protection to their own employees, the Government of India would not be responsible for their safety.” It added that “all these diplomats sent their Muslim employees and domestic servants to the various refugee camps. … It is also significant that Lord Mountbatten was not able to protect his own Muslim employees and domestic servants, some of whom were killed and wounded.” If these reports are true, they would shatter the myth of empire being a benevolent, benign force, and expose it as ruthless and vengeful, even in its dying days. Grand Mufti’s letter This newspaper’s commitment to the Palestinian cause goes back to the time of Independence. In fact, Haj Amin Al-Hussaini, the Grand Mufti of Al-Quds, had written to Dawn asking the paper to raise awareness about Palestine’s plight. As chronicled in the Sept 28 issue, Haj Amin wrote that “Undoubtedly you know the dangers threatening Palestine because of the Zionist imperialistic aims, and because of the decisions of the United Nations’ Special Committee on Palestine in dividing Palestine into two States — an Arab and a Jewish — although the majority of the Jews in Palestine are foreigners who entered Palestine by force of British arms after the British occupation. “We are in urgent need of your help to raise your strong voice in disapproving the UNSCOP report and to do your best in order to save Palestine, the first Qiblah and the third Masjid from the dangers threatening her.” Haj Amin was a prescient man and could see what was coming for his people. Sadly, 79 years after the Mufti’s impassioned appeal, the people of Palestine continue to suffer from Zionist terrorism. With the advantage of hindsight, one has the opportunity to study the historical cycles in a nation’s life. Thanks to this newspaper’s unique, extensive archive of back issues, one can examine the major political, economic and social trends that have shaped Pakistan and the world over the last seven decades and counting. Cliched as it may sound, history repeats itself, and we — as a state and as a polity — largely refuse to learn from it. Through this platform, we will look back at the ‘big’ stories that made it to the front pages of Dawn, as well as significant developments tucked away in the inside pages, from the birth of Pakistan onwards, and try to put them in perspective. We will study the critical issues of the week, starting from Aug 14, 1947 and examine the major themes and issues that made it to the paper.
Curation & Context
This page summarizes a public news report from dawn.com. Global News Hub provides the "Why This Matters" takeaway using editorial insights and AI curation to give readers rapid, high-value context before they click through to read the full article.